What Retail Results tell us about Consumer Confidence

Inteligex • Nov 17, 2022

Inflation, inflation, inflation ......... that's all we keep hearing about at the moment. Inflation drives prices up making your weekly shop more expensive. When items cost more money we tend to cut back on spending or look for cheaper alternatives so the performance of Retailers gives us a great guide to real consumer confidence particularly for the forthcoming Holiday Season.  So what are Retailers saying?


Well the results are giving different signals, not unlike the official economic data that is out there.  In this Q3 earnings season a host of Retailers have already reported. 


Updates from Lowes and Home Depot suggested that demand for building, home improvement and maintenance products is holding up.  Amazon sees signs of consumer weakness in Q4 whereas Walmart reported good numbers and predicts a good holiday season (also saying it has captured more affluent consumers who are now looking for cheaper prices).


So it was with interest that we awaited Target's earnings. When these came out they were not well received, resulting in a 15% share price drop.  But it's the detail that is more interesting here.  In the latter weeks of the 3rd quarter Target said that "sales and profit trends softened meaningfully, with guests' shopping behavior increasingly impacted by inflation, rising interest rates and economic uncertainty".  This means they have downgraded their guidance for Q4 which includes the all important Holiday Season.


At a high level Target and Walmart are fairly similar propositions so what is the big difference and what is it really telling us about the robustness of consumer spending?  Target arguably has more discretionary spend items than Walmart and this seems to be the key here.  The company update shows that shoppers are increasingly only buying goods that are on sale and they've been shifting spend to private label goods, smaller pack sizes and larger sizes that are on promotion. Specifically sales of home items, sporting goods and toys have lagged though food/beverages have held their own.  


Importantly Target doesn't seem to have attracted as many more affluent customers who are moving down to find cheaper prices so arguably Target's update gives us a more accurate view of their consumer demographic.  It's telling us consumers are hurting and the increasing inflation is taking it's toll!


Another negative indicator coming from Target is so called 'shrink', which is basically theft.  They said that shoplifting has been getting worse and it the company has taken a write down of more than $400 million so far this year.  This is another sign that consumers are hurting.


So what does it all mean?  Well it's clear evidence that inflation is already hurting consumers and with it unlikely to come down significantly in the next few months it will have an impact well into 2023.  Maybe the impact in Lowes and Home Depot will lag slightly because projects won't immediately get cancelled but they will also see the impact too.  Remember the Fed is committed to getting the inflation back to 2% so there is a lot of work to be done and unfortunately a lot more pain to be felt as interest rates continue to increase.


This means that it's a difficult time to invest, most analysts are expecting reduced earnings next year and therefore don't think the market has hit the bottom. However, it could be a great time to think about trading: the markets move up and down everyday and that's where many banks are making good money.



The Inteligex Trading System gives you award winning, proven Trade Signals and Indicators.  Our extensive machine learning and sophisticated algorithms effectively predict market movements and price points.  It's simple to learn and easy to use, we teach you everything you need to know and support you throughout your trading journey.


To see what Inteligex can do for you, book your FREE no obligation Personal Consultation below.



BOOK NOW
photo of Charlie Munger in a business suit
By Peter Northwood 29 Nov, 2023
We look at the amazing impact that Charlie has left on generations of stockpickers and investors.
A trading screen and candlestick chart on a phone
By Peter Northwood 13 Nov, 2023
Hedge Funds and Big Banks have been using AI capability for many years, now it is available to Retail Traders.
By Peter Northwood 10 Nov, 2023
AI presents enormous global opportunities, but there could also have some nasty downsides. The recent Global AI Summit started the journey on how to regulate this wild west sector.
explosion on the horizon
By Peter Northwood 19 Oct, 2023
Geopolitical risk is a fact of life, but what does it mean for your Trading and Investing?
By Peter Northwood 03 Oct, 2023
Ahead of the all important Q4 season we assess what's driving the economy and what's holding it back.
hundred dollar bills on a US flat
By Peter Northwood 22 Aug, 2023
With US Government Treasury yields at a 16 year high, have bonds overtaken stocks as the growth engine for investors?
By Peter Northwood 07 Aug, 2023
If you're an investor then timing the markets is almost impossible, but there is an alternative!
By Peter Northwood 27 Jul, 2023
With jobs data still strong will the Fed have to break the labor market and cause a recession to get inflation back to 2%.
$100 bills in a briefcase
By Peter Northwood 11 Jul, 2023
Why are get-rich-quick schemes so prevalent and how do you avoid them?
levels in a field
By Peter Northwood 06 Jul, 2023
Higher time frames have stronger lines of support and resistance, we show you how to identify those Daily Levels and add them to your charts.
More Posts
Share by: